There is a fantastic selection of Cayuga Lake wineries in the Finger Lakes, producing award-winning Cayuga wines that reflect the region’s unique cold-climate character. Many of these Cayuga wineries are locally owned by passionate farmers, sommeliers, and wine lovers who are dedicated to sustainable practices and making delicious wines. While there are more than 150 Finger Lakes wineries across the region, focusing on a specific area, such as the wineries on Cayuga Lake, offers a more intimate and flavorful way to explore.
The Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, established in 1983 as America’s first wine trail, leads you through some of the most scenic vineyards and tasting rooms in the Finger Lakes. With more than a dozen stops, including wineries, cideries, distilleries, and a meadery, this route offers a well-rounded tasting experience. From the shores near Taughannock Falls to the rolling hills of Trumansburg, each Cayuga Lake winery showcases handcrafted wines, stunning lake views, and the welcoming hospitality that defines the best Cayuga Lake wineries.
Before you start filling your itinerary exploring the Cayuga Lake wineries, you’ll want to secure your overnight lodging. There is so much to discover, more than just wine, so a getaway here could span multiple days, and you would still find more new things for your next trip. Our Bed and Breakfast in the Finger Lakes is located in the charming storybook village of Trumansburg, placing you minutes from the wineries on Cayuga Lake and offering the perfect spot to relax after a day of exploration. Book your stay today!
Best Cayuga Lake Wineries in the Finger Lakes
While there are countless Finger Lakes wineries, the west side of Cayuga Lake is especially rich in award-winning producers. The Cayuga Lake Wine Trail is an excellent starting point for itineraries and tour options, and we highly recommend arranging a guided experience with Experience! The Finger Lakes. Recognized by USA Today as one of the nation’s 10 Best Wine Tour Companies for four consecutive years, they provide door-to-door transportation to and from our Inn to some of the best Cayuga wineries on the lake, a seamless way to enjoy tastings at the best winery Cayuga Lake has to offer.
Here are our favorite Cayuga Lake wineries to include on your tasting journey:
- Established in 1987, Six Mile Creek Vineyard is one of the oldest Cayuga Lake wineries and distilleries. It is located in a restored 19th-century Dutch Colonial barn and offers a diverse selection of wines and spirits, including award-winning varieties like its 2016 Cabernet Franc, which won the prestigious Governor’s Cup in 2019. Their reds, especially Cabernet Sauvignon, have become guest favorites.
- For over four decades, Lucas Vineyards has been a standout among Cayuga wineries. Friendly staff, lush vineyards, and beautiful Cayuga Lake views set the tons for a memorable tasting. Expect estate-grown vinifera, méthode champenoise sparkling wines, iced wines, sangria, and their famous nautical-inspired “Tug Boat” and “Nautie” wines. Their Pinot Noir and Rieslings are consistently praised.
- Hosmer Winery is a family-owned estate producing award-winning wines from its 70-acre Patrician Verona Vineyard. Known for varietals such as Riesling, Cabernet Sauvignon, and Pinot Noir, the winery emphasizes sustainable farming practices to reflect its site’s unique terroir. A guided tasting here offers a thoughtful introduction to the best Cayuga Lake wineries.
- Perched on 150 acres along the western shore in Ovid, New York, Thirsty Owl Wine Co. offers a diverse selection of estate-grown wines, including Riesling, Pinot Gris, Malbec, Syrah, and Pinot Noir. This Cayuga Lake winery offers tastings in a spacious room with stunning lake views. During the season, dine at the on-site bistro, which features local ingredients. It’s one of the most beloved wineries on Cayuga Lake.
- Cayuga Ridge Estate Winery is often considered a contender for the best winery Cayuga Lake offers. This rustic and elegant stop features estate-grown wines that reflect skill, passion, and heart. The atmosphere inside its charming barn, lit by Gothic church lights, makes tasting here especially memorable.
- Buttonwood Grove Winery offers exceptional Cayuga wines, from classic European grape varieties such as Chardonnay, Cabernet Franc, Riesling, and an expanding selection of red varietals. Their multi-level deck overlooks Cayuga Lake, making this one of the most picturesque Cayuga Lake wineries on the trail.
The Best Bed and Breakfast in the Finger Lakes
Each morning, you can start your stay at our Bed and Breakfast in the Finger Lakes in our elegant dining room or sunroom off the kitchen. You’ll enjoy our housemade sweet and savory treats, always paired with hot coffee, teas, and more. We take pride in serving fresh, organic, and locally sourced ingredients, reflecting the same regional dedication to quality found in the surrounding Cayuga Lake wineries.
Our guest rooms offer a luxurious and intimate retreat after a day of exploring Cayuga Lake wineries and winding rural backroads in Upstate New York. Each elegantly designed room features plush bedding, modern amenities, and private baths. Select rooms offer cozy fireplaces, spa tubs, or private outdoor seating, ideal for unwinding with a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon or Pinot Noir from your favorite Cayuga Lake winery.
To complete your getaway, book a rejuvenating session at The Spa at Gothic Eves. Our spa offers specialized healing services, including Reiki, Crystal Therapy, and personalized massage therapy. You’ll also find an infrared sauna with mood light therapy and an integrated sound system to enhance relaxation. Whether you’re here to explore the wineries on Cayuga Lake, relax in comfort, or experience the broader charm of the Finger Lakes, our Inn offers a refined stay with regional flavor. Book your lodging today!
Find out more about the experience at our Inn on our social media channels: Facebook & Instagram.
