One of the best parts of vacationing, or even just getting away for a quick retreat from the city, is dining out! You never know what you’ll discover, and the selection of farm-to-table options at these restaurants in the Finger Lakes is astounding! This area of Upstate New York is known for its local farms and wineries, creating a bounty of fresh-grown goods and products to try.
One of our favorite local restaurants in the Finger Lakes is Hazelnut Kitchen, tucked away in the charming village of Trumansburg. Chef Matt Hummel leads the charge at this locally-owned hidden gem. As a Trumanburg native, Hummel aims to work with nearby purveyors and farmers whenever possible, bringing fresh and flavorful cuisine to his menu. The cozy dining space is ideal for date night!
Before you start making your dinner plans, you’ll want to secure your lodging in the area, and our Finger Lakes Bed and Breakfast is one of the best places to stay. You’ll start your day with a lovely homemade breakfast prepared with love and care at the Inn. We also support local farms and even grow our own produce when feasible. You’ll be welcomed with open arms and love, starting your day with us at the Inn at Gothic Eves. Book your room today!
The Best Restaurants in the Finger Lakes
Dining out is such an essential element to any successful romantic getaway, couple’s trip, or solo retreat. Eating at the local restaurants in the Finger Lakes is more than just a meal: it’s a look inside the love and care we take with our food in this area. With so many local farms producing beautiful fresh products, you’ll taste the difference!
Here are our favorite restaurants in the Finger Lakes to try on your visit:
- Hazelnut Kitchen: A Trumansburg fixture, this local eatery has been serving since 2007 but recently sold to chef Matt Hummel, who is continuing the farm-to-table aspect of the space. The menu changes with the seasons, and the dining room is a welcoming space for locals and visitors alike to enjoy a beautiful meal.
- Main Street Market: For organic lunch fare and local goods, this market in Trumansburg is a must during your stay! They have lovely salads, sandwiches, and sweet treats to enjoy there or take to go.
- Finger Lakes Cider House: For an immersive farm experience, this cider house in Interlaken, NY, has it all. From cidery and farm tours to tastings and live music, this is one of the restaurants in the Finger Lakes offering more than just a meal.
- Dano’s Heuriger on Seneca: For a traditional Viennese meal with a stunning lake view, Dano’s is one of the most unique restaurants in the Finger Lakes. Guests are encouraged to take their time, sip their wine, and fully experience this dining style.
- Ithaca Beer Company: This farm brewery and taproom is just outside Ithaca between two state parks, perfect for a post-hike beer and meal. This well-known brewery has a few locations around town.
- Gola Osteria: This local hidden gem is a favorite for date night. For a classic Italian feast with a modern twist here and there, indulge in handmade pasta with luscious sauces and seasonal ingredients and savor every last drop of the delicious Italian wines.
- The Heights Cafe: Located in Ithaca, just one mile from the historic Cornell University, this stalwart Mediterranean-inspired restaurant serves artfully designed small plates, entrees, and handcrafted pizzas. Pro tip: save room for dessert!
- FLX Table: While this spot is about 45 minutes from our Finger Lakes Bed and Breakfast, if you’re already out and about wine tasting near Geneva, a five-course dinner here is bound to be unforgettable. This is one of the restaurants in the Finger Lakes featured in Wine & Spirits magazine—you’ll need to make reservations in advance.
One of the Best Places to Stay in the Finger Lakes
Imagine waking up refreshed in your own private guest suite, where only the peaceful sounds of our garden grounds greet you. A fresh, home-cooked breakfast is waiting in our dining room. We provide light and healthful meals packed with the ideal nutrients your body needs, sourced from local farms and made with skill and care. We hit the Trumansburg Farmers Market whenever possible, so on a getaway here, you’ll get a taste of what our area can do.
After your morning meal, the rest of the day is up to you: explore our grounds, head directly to the spa, or even just relish your downtime in your elegant guest suite. Beautiful spring and summer days are best spent at the nearby state parks, on the lakefronts, and out in the countryside, and the evenings can be enjoyed over delicious meals and locally-produced wine at the restaurants in the Finger Lakes!
There’s something magical about staying at a unique lodging property during a quick getaway in Upstate New York. Unlike large chain hotels, our Finger Lakes Bed and Breakfast offers personalized and welcoming hospitality, one-of-a-kind guest suites, and beautiful spaces that create lasting memories. Start planning your next getaway and book your stay at the Inn at Gothic Eves today!
